请教下：可靠性方面的软件有哪些？各自优缺点？

relexrelisoft的可以去了解一下。

其实可靠性软件这方面是有比较多的，就如各个可靠性设备厂商来讲，都各有特点，每个厂商提供的软件都主要是记录整个试验过程，详细的分析产品的好坏

relxex(超贵,培训也很差劲),relisoft(价格还可以,培训做得很不错)andMinitab

国内电子五所的CARMES怎么样

可以自己分别调查一下，试用一下，感受一下，就知道了

item和Isograp

以下是主要的可靠性软件供应商，希望能对你有帮助 FailureModes,EffectsandCriticalityAnalysis(FMECA) • SabatonFMEA/FMECA(Sydvest) • Xfmea(ReliaSoft) • ReliabilityWorkbench-FMECA(Isograph) • FMECAModule(ModuleifItemToolkit)(ItemUK)(ItemUS) • ITEMQa(FMEA)(ItemUK) • RelexFMEA/FMECA(Relex) • FMECA(ModuleofRAMCommander)(A.L.D.)alsosoldbyReliass • ProFMEA(A.L.D.) • Failcab(CABInnov) • FMEAplus(FORD) • FMEAPro6(Dyadem)alsosoldbyReliass • FMEA6forMedicalDevices(Dyadem) • IQ-FMEA • RiskSpectrumFMEA(RelconAB) • ASENT(Raytheon)alsosoldbyReliass • PHAWorks(PrimaTech) • PHA-Pro6(Dyadem) • FMEA(SoHaR) • TDCFMEA • CAREFMEA(BQR) FaultTreeConstructionandAnalysis • CARAFaultTree(Sydvest) • SAPHIRE • RiskSpectrumFTProfessional(RelconAB) • FaultTreeAnalysisModule(ModuleofItemToolkit)(ItemUK)(ItemUS) • LOGAN(RMConsultants)alsosoldbyReliass • RelexFaultTree(Relex) • FTA(ModuleofRAMCommander)(A.L.D.)alsosoldbyReliass • Cabtree(CABInnov) • FaultTree+(Isograph) • FaultrEASE(ArthurD.Little) • FTAnalyzerLite(SoHaR) • CAFTA • CAREFTA(BQR) ReliabilityBlockDiagrams • RelexRBD(Relex) • ReliabilityWorkbench-ReliabilityBlockDiagram(Isograph) • RBDModule(ModuleofItemToolkit)(ItemUK)(ItemUS) • BlockSim(ReliaSoft) • ASENT(Raytheon)alsosoldbyReliass • RBD(ModuleofRAMCommander)(A.L.D.)alsosoldbyReliass • Supercab(CABInnov) • CARERBD(BQR) MarkovAnalysis • FaultTree+-Markov(Isograph) • MarkovAnalysis(ModuleofItemToolkit)(ItemUK)(ItemUS) • RelexMarkov(Relex) • MEADEP(SoHaR)alsosoldbyReliass • Supercab(CABInnov) • CARE-RBD-Markov(BQR) SystemEffectivenessAnalysis • MAROS(JardineGroup) • MIRIAMRegina • LOGANMonteCarlo(RMConsultants)alsosoldbyReliass • AvSim+(Isograph) • RelexOpSim(Relex) • RAMPRAM4(Advantage)alsosoldbyReliass • RaptoralsosoldbyReliass • CAME(BQR) SystemReliability(RAM)Assessment • RAMCommander(A.L.D.)alsosoldbyReliass • BlockSim(ReliaSoft) • MEADEP(SoHaR)alsosoldbyReliass • ITEMToolkit(ItemUK)(ItemUS) • ASENT(Raytheon)alsosoldbyReliass • AvSim+(Isograph) • RaptoralsosoldbyReliass • CARE-RBD(BQR) ComponentReliabilityPrediction • PRISM(RAC)alsosoldbyReliass • RELEXReliabilityPredictionSoftware • ReliabilityWorkbench-MIL-HDBK217(Isograph) • ReliabilityWorkbench-TelcordiaSR323(Isograph) • ReliabilityWorkbench-NSWC-98(Isograph) • ReliabilityWorkbench-RDF2000(Isograph) • ReliabilityWorkbench-GJB/Z299B(Isograph) • ITEMToolkit:MIL-217Module(ItemUK)(ItemUS) • ITEMToolkit:BellcoreModule(ItemUK)(ItemUS) • ITEMToolkit:NSWCMechanicalModule(ItemUK)(ItemUS) • ASENT(Raytheon)alsosoldbyReliass • RAMCommander-217(A.L.D.)alsosoldbyReliass • RAMCommander-Belcore/Telcordia(A.L.D.)alsosoldbyReliass • RAMCommander-CNETRDF(A.L.D.)alsosoldbyReliass • RAMCommander-UTECC80810(A.L.D.)alsosoldbyReliass • CARE-M217(BQR) • CARE-Bellcore(BQR) • CARE-UTECC80810(BQR) • CARE-Siemens(BQR) • CARE-CNET(BQR) FunctionalSafetyAnalysis • SILence(Manualinpdf-format)(HIMA) • SILver(SafetyIntegrityLevelVerificationTool)(exida) • SILect&SRS(SILSelection&SafetyRequirementSpecificationTool)(exida) FRACAS-FailureReportingandCorrectiveActionSystem • FRACASCorrectiveActionSoftware(Relex) • QTMS(ReliaSoft) • FRACAS(Isograph) • ASENT(Raytheon)alsosoldbyReliass • FavoWebalsosoldbyReliass LifeDataAnalysis • Weibull++(ReliaSoft) • RelexFailureDataAnalysis(Relex) • RelexWeibull(Relex) • AvSim+-WeibullAnalysis(Isograph) • CAfdE(BQR) AcceleratedLifeTesting • ALTA(ReliaSoft) ReliabilityGrowthAnalysis • RGA6(ReliaSoft) • CAfdE(BQR) MaintenancePlanningandOptimizationMaintenance • RelexMaintainabilityPrediction(Relex) • RCMCost(Isograph) • MPC-3(ReliaSoft) • ORBIT(DNV) • MAINTAIN(ModuleofItemToolkit) • SPARECOST(ModuleofItemToolkit)(ItemUK)(ItemUS) • MANIFER(Former"RCMTool") • Maintainability(ModuleofRAMCommander)(A.L.D.)alsosoldbyReliass • ASENT(Raytheon)alsosoldbyReliass • CAMERCM(BQR) LiceCycleCost(LCC) • RelexLCC(Relex) • D-LCC(A.L.D.)alsosoldbyReliass • LCCWare(Isograph) • CAMELCC(BQR) RiskAnalysis • RiskSpectrumPSAProfessional(RelconAB) • QRAS(ItemUK)(ItemUS) • PHAST(DNV) • NEPTUNE(DNV) • SAFETI(DNV) • KYRASS(Sydvest-InNorwegian) • Failcab-PreliminaryRiskAanalysis(CABInnov) • ASAP(LilleakerConsulting) • COSAC-ConceptSafetyCatalogue • BlowFAM-BlowoutFrequencyAssessmentMethod • LEAK(DNV) • RiskVu(Isograph) • FaultTree+(Isograph) • LOGAN(RMConsultants)alsosoldbyReliass • PHA-Pro6(Dyadem)alsosoldbyReliass EventTreeAnalysis • RiskSpectrumPSAProfessional(RelconAB) • RelexEventTree(Relex) • ETA(SAIC) • LOGAN(RMConsultants)alsosoldbyReliass • FaultTree+-EventTreeAnalysis(Isograph) HAZOP • Hazop+(Isograph) • PHA-Pro6(Dyadem)alsosoldbyReliass • HAZOPtimizer(ArthurD.Little) • HAZOP(Lihou) • HAZOPTOOL(VTT) • PHAWorks(PrimaTech) [[i]本帖最后由dachqian于2007-9-311:35编辑[/i]]

总的来说，软件基本功能相差不多，都是基于已有标准，都有十几年二十年的的商业化过程．

[quote]原帖由[i]dachqian[/i]于2007-9-121:48发表[url=http://www.kekaoxing.com/club/redirect.php?goto=findpost&pid=7977&ptid=701][/url] 以下是主要的可靠性软件供应商，西望能对你有帮助 FailureModes,EffectsandCriticalityAnalysis(FMECA) • SabatonFMEA/FMECA(Sydvest) • Xfmea(ReliaSoft) • Reliabilit...[/quote] 这些可靠性软件，很多都没有听过，惭愧！！:L 再次感谢楼上朋友的介绍。。

[quote]原帖由[i]admin[/i]于2007-9-309:39发表[url=http://www.kekaoxing.com/club/redirect.php?goto=findpost&pid=8081&ptid=701][/url] 感谢admin对我的肯定，我也只是略有了解。 个人认为：可靠性预计故障树分析用软件会带来很多便利。 但是软件还是远远不够。提高设计能力制造能力管理能力和引导用户正常合理规范的使用才是根本。 个人浅见望各位也谈谈自己的看法。